Be sure to respond to the poll at the end of the article! 

More than Two Cups: Arsenal’s Century of Supremacy over Chelsea BY Miles Lesser

In 1934, Arsenal went to Stamford Bridge and clinched the league title on Chelsea’s own field, a statement that emphasized Arsenal’s dominance over Chelsea. It was the kind of championship moment that lives rent-free in the heads of Chelsea fans.

That moment matters because it is a moment that encapsulates the century that followed. Arsenal became the constant, the standard, the club that epitomizes the identity of English football. Meanwhile, Chelsea have surged, collapsed, rebranded, risen again, and collapsed again. That instability is a large part of the story between two of the biggest clubs in the world. When you look at the Premier League structure, promotion, relegation, and the brutal schedule of English football, longevity actually means something. Measured by those standards, Arsenal towers over Chelsea. Arsenal has 13 league titles, including the iconic unbeaten “invincibles” season. Chelsea only has six league titles. Arsenal have lifted a record 14 FA Cups, while Chelsea has only had eight. While Arsenal have only been relegated once, way back in 1913, Chelsea have gone down six times, most recently in 1988. You don’t just have to take my word as a fan, as even neutral figures acknowledge the gap between the clubs. Gary Neville, Manchester United legend, said, “Arsenal are a bigger club than Chelsea. They are, it’s a fact.”  

Chelsea fans have one argument against Arsenal’s success, which is that they have more UEFA Champions League titles. While yes, Chelsea has two Champions League titles, which were two iconic runs in 2012 and 2021. However, two isolated peaks don’t outweigh a century of domestic achievements. The Champions League is a high-variance tournament; English clubs have won it just 15 times in 70 years, despite England claiming the strongest league on earth. Great teams lose to a team when the goalkeeper becomes locked down, or a wild bounce that leads to the only scoring chance, or even just a freak injury. You can’t measure all-time superiority by two magical moments. 

If history and trophies feel like an old metric, the modern game has another angle where spending power is the great equalizer, or the great excuse, depending on which club you support. Arsenal and Chelsea both operate near the top of the Premier League’s financial hierarchy, but the efficiency with which each club converts money into results paints a very different picture. In the 2024-25 season, Arsenal earned 74 points while spending €15,675,675 per point, while Chelsea earned only 69 points, spending €17,246,376 per point. This isn’t a one-off occurrence; it has been repeated year after year, as seen in the table below:

Every season, the conclusion is the same: Arsenal consistently gets more value for their spending, Chelsea essentially light money on fire, and Arsenal turns it into points. While the two spend at similar levels, the difference is the efficiency. 

We can even look at the team’s current squads. This season, three Arsenal bench players could easily fit into Chelsea’s starting XI: Gabriel Martinelli, Cristhian Mosquera, and Mikel Merino. The numbers back it up as well. Mosquera has an average FotMob rating of 6.72. While Chelsea’s starting Center Back, Wesley Fofana, has an average FotMob rating of 6.57. Merino’s average FotMob rating of 7.08 greatly exceeds Liam Delap’s of 6.02. That’s all before you get to Gabriel Martinelli, who is objectively better than anything Chelsea has out wide right now. Arsenal have depth; Chelsea have names. One of those wins matches, one wins brand engagement. 

This debate of Arsenal vs. Chelsea isn’t just about who lifts more trophies in a single season; it’s a conversation that stretches across generations and will continue for many more. It shows what truly defines a “big” club: sustained success, smart management, and the ability to leave a lasting mark on fans and football culture. While Chelsea has had spectacular peaks, Arsenal’s century-long consistency sets the standard for measuring greatness. This discussion reflects a broader tension in football between flash and legacy, money and tradition, short-term glory and long-term impact. Fifty years from now, this rivalry will still spark arguments, stories, and debates, just as it has for those who came before. The bigger lesson is clear: football greatness isn’t just won with trophies, it’s earned over a decade, and passed from one generation to the next. London will forever be red. 

Chelsea FC is the biggest club in London BY Harshil Bhatia

Walk into any pub, any restaurant, any house in London, and you’ll hear the same argument everywhere. Which is the bigger club, Chelsea or Arsenal? This question turns even the best of friends into enemies. For generations, people have been arguing this. Arsenal fans are talking about their dusty, ancient trophies won decades ago. And Chelsea fans are celebrating major wins up until this day. When the conversation becomes Arsenal talking about their nostalgia instead of any recent accomplishments, it becomes clear that Chelsea is the largest club in London.

One of the biggest reasons why Chelsea is bigger than Arsenal is the trophy cabinet. Chelsea has won every major trophy ever in modern football, including two Champions League titles, one of the hardest trophies ever to get. Something Arsenal has never achieved. Chelsea also has a Europa League, Club World Cup, Super Cup, and Conference League, something Arsenal does not have. While Arsenal fans like to brag about their league titles from decades ago, the last 20 years have been dominated by Chelsea, winning more Premier League titles and consistently performing on the largest European stage. Arsenal’s recent success consists of FA cups and Community Shields – trophies that are irrelevant. According to Pep Guardiola, who is regarded as one of the greatest football managers of all time. “The Community Shield? Nobody counts it, that’s the question, I would like an answer.” The difference between the accomplishments of the two giants is enormous and keeps growing.

Another major factor in Chelsea’s supremacy is the culture of its fan base: Arsenal fans have built a reputation for delusion that is unmatched in the Premier League. In a professional debate between verified club-appointed fans, in the discussion of the greatest RW ever to bless the Premier League, one fan had the audacity to mention Bukayo Saka as one of them. This is an outrageous statement, as the stats totally disprove it. Cristiano Ronaldo, one of the greatest athletes in the world, was a right winger in the Premier League. Bukayo Saka isn’t even up to 1% of his level. Ronaldo has more goals than Saka has matches played, and has the 10th most trophies in the soccer world. Arsenal fans also struggle with match reality. Alan Shearer, who is the Premier League’s all-time top goal scorer, shared his disappointment with Arsenal in an interview after seeing them celebrate a second-place win.

Chelsea has constantly had better players than Arsenal across all of the Premier League decades. Didier Drogba, who scored in multiple finals and scored an equalizer in the final that made Chelsea champions of Europe. Thierry Henry, on the other hand, who is regarded as Arsenal’s greatest player, has never scored in any final in his entire career. Frank Lampard, the highest-scoring midfielder ever in the Premier League, and John Terry, who has the highest goals and clean sheets in the Premier League as a defender, are some of the legends that Chelsea have. Petr Cech, who has the most clean sheets in the Premier League as a goalkeeper, with the majority being at Chelsea. Chelsea also has current top-level talents like Cole Palmer, who has nearly matched Saka’s goal contributions in fewer minutes as a midfielder, and has already won more trophies. Enzo Fernandez, a World Cup winner, and Moises Caicedo, the greatest DM in the world at the moment, help complete this legendary midfield trio. Chelsea have only taken 15 players from Arsenal compared to Arsenal taking 20 players from Chelsea. Players that Chelsea have taken from Arsenal have tended to win more and do better than they did during their times at Arsenal, and not vice versa. Kai Havertz won the Champions League at Chelsea and then went trophyless at Arsenal for the rest of the season. 

One might argue that Chelsea has spent money on our success, but Chelsea’s transfers have been business strategies, as Todd Boehly, Chelsea’s owner, is a businessman after all. Arsenal has spent 1.38 billion in the last 10 years, and Chelsea has made 2.78 billion in the last 10 years, but Chelsea has used half that money to sell players to other clubs. So, after we look at how much money Chelsea has made back, we have spent 1.75 billion dollars, close to how much  Arsenal spent in the last 10 years. Chelsea spent the most money in 2022, and since then, they have made almost all the money back and won 3 trophies. 

When you look at the last two decades of football, it becomes clear that Chelsea is the biggest club in London. The debate will always be there about who is bigger, but Chelsea will always come out on top. More legacy, more heritage, and more global influence. Arsenal will forever spend their years celebrating second place, while Chelsea will go on to dominate European football.